We’re diving deep into a topic that’s generating a lot of buzz—and a lot of confusion—in the cybersecurity world: the difference between resilience and restoration.
“Resilience” is fast becoming a favorite buzzword, but what does it actually mean for your security program? Is it just a new name for disaster recovery? Not quite.
Understanding the distinction is crucial. It’s the difference between simply getting back on your feet after an attack and building an organization that can withstand and adapt to almost anything thrown its way. Let’s anchor our discussion on the gold standard, NIST, to understand what these terms practically mean for you.
Think of resilience as your organization’s ability to take a punch. It’s not just about surviving the hit, but about preparing for it, adapting during the chaos, and recovering rapidly afterward.
NIST provides a solid definition:
Resilience is the ability to prepare for and adapt to changing conditions and to withstand and recover rapidly from disruptions. This includes the ability to deal with deliberate attacks, accidents, or naturally occurring threats.
Resilience isn’t just a post-incident activity. It covers the entire timeline of an event, which security pros often call “left of boom” and “right of boom.”
Left of Boom: The “good times” before an incident happens. This is where you prepare, harden systems, and plan. How resilient is your domain controller to a failure? How well can your router handle a flood of traffic?
The Boom: The disruptive event itself—a ransomware attack, a hardware failure, a natural disaster.
Right of Boom: The period after the event. This is where you respond, recover, and learn.
Resilience is a continuous state. It applies to everything from a single IT system to a complex industrial control network at a power plant or refinery. It’s about ensuring the business function can continue, no matter the adversity.
If resilience is the entire triathlon, restoration is the final, critical sprint to the finish line.
While NIST doesn’t have a single formal definition for restoration, the concept is woven throughout its guidance. Restoration is the specific act of returning your systems and operations to full, 100% capacity after a disruption.
It’s an essential component of resilience.
Think of it this way: your disaster recovery plan might get you up and running at a temporary co-op site, operating at 60% efficiency. That’s recovery. Restoration is the process of moving back to your primary site and getting that efficiency meter back to 100%.
Here’s where many organizations miss the mark. We tend to silo our thinking into “IT systems” and “OT systems.” But resilience and restoration are about protecting the business process that the technology enables.
Consider a utility company. Is their billing system an “IT” problem? On the surface, yes. But what happens if that billing system goes down?
The company can’t track usage.
It can’t generate invoices.
It can’t collect revenue.
Suddenly, that “IT” system is crippling the core business function. A utility can’t give away power for free. Therefore, restoring the billing system is just as critical to the business’s resilience as protecting the power generation turbines.
So, how do you build this capability? It starts with a solid planning framework. NIST’s Special Publication 800-34 Rev. 1, Contingency Planning Guide for Federal Information Systems, offers an excellent (and free) roadmap.
While you don’t need to adopt every single plan, understanding them helps you cover all your bases. Key plans include:
Business Continuity Plan (BCP): Procedures for sustaining essential business operations during a disruption.
Continuity of Operations (COOP) Plan: How to keep operations running from an alternate site.
Crisis Communications Plan: How you’ll communicate internally and externally. The recent cyberattacks on MGM highlight how critical this is, especially when state gaming commissions and other regulators are involved. What you say publicly matters—immensely.
Cyber Incident Response (IR) Plan: The tactical plan for detecting, analyzing, and mitigating a cyberattack.
Disaster Recovery (DR) Plan: The plan for relocating and recovering systems at an alternate location.
But for mastering restoration, one plan stands out…
Your Incident Response plan is designed to stop the bleeding. But it won’t guide you through the complex process of getting your business back to 100%. That’s the job of the Information System Contingency Plan (ISCP).
The ISCP is your detailed guide for full recovery and restoration after the immediate incident is contained. Developing one forces you to look inward, away from the latest threat feeds, and focus on what truly matters: your core business operations.
The process of creating an ISCP typically follows these steps:
Develop Policy: Align the plan with business goals and regulatory requirements.
Conduct a Business Impact Analysis (BIA): This is the most critical step.
Create Contingency Strategies: Define your approach to recovery.
Develop the Plan: Write down the detailed procedures.
Test, Train, and Exercise: Use tabletop exercises and real-world drills to validate the plan. Don’t just talk about it—have participants role-play and follow the actual steps.
Maintain the Plan: This is a living document. It must be updated as your business, technology, and threats change.
If your ISCP is the roadmap, the Business Impact Analysis (BIA) is the GPS that makes it accurate. An inaccurate BIA will lead you astray when it matters most.
Here’s how a BIA works:
Identify Business Processes: List the critical functions your organization performs (e.g., “Generate customer invoices,” “Process refinery crude oil”).
Determine Tolerable Downtime: For each process, ask: how long can this be down before we face severe consequences? This is your Recovery Time Objective (RTO) target.
Map to System Components: Connect each business process to the specific IT and OT components it relies on (e.g., “The billing process depends on the Oracle database, the main web server, and the domain controller”).
Establish a Realistic RTO: Now, for those critical components, determine a realistic RTO. Be honest. Factor in the time it will take to even detect the problem, assemble your team, and bring in vendors. A plan based on wishful thinking is a plan to fail.
Once this BIA is complete, it informs the three core phases of your ISCP: Activation and Notification, Recovery, and Reconstitution (the final restoration phase).
Resilience and restoration are not interchangeable, but they are deeply connected.
Resilience is your overarching strategy to prepare for, withstand, and adapt to any disruption.
Restoration is the specific, planned capability to get your business back to full strength after an incident.
By focusing on your critical business processes and building a robust Information System Contingency Plan (ISCP), you move beyond a reactive stance. You build a program that doesn’t just recover—it endures.
What’s the biggest challenge your organization faces in building resilience?
Our products are designed to work with
you and keep your network protected.